A Charitable Remainder
Trust is set up in order to achieve both income and estate tax benefits
for a donor and the donor's beneficiaries. A properly established charitable remainder trust is eligible for a charitable
estate-tax deduction on the decedent's estate tax return.
However, if a charitable
remainder trust is generating income that is reinvested by the clients, the projected value of those additional investments
needs to be taken into account in order to have an accurate estate projection.
The donor
names individuals (which may include the donor) to receive income from the trust for life, with the principal remaining at
the donor's death going to the designated charity.
The donor
receives an income tax deduction when property is transferred to the trust, and the size of the estate is reduced by a charitable
deduction (in the amount of property transferred) at the donor's death.
Naturally,
there are restrictions placed on the non-charitable beneficiary's rights to income and the invasion of the trust principal.
Only in this way can the designated charity be assured that it will eventually receive the property for which the donor is
taking income tax deductions.
Two
of the most utilized Charitable Remainder Trusts are the Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust and the Charitable Remainder Unitrust.
What Is a Charitable Remainder
Trust (CRT)?
With certain important exceptions,
gifts to charity of partial interests in property, (gifts of less than the donor’s entire interest in property), do
not qualify for the income tax, gift tax or estate tax charitable deduction. One of the most important exceptions to this
"partial-interest rule" is for gifts made to charity through charitable remainder trusts that meet statutory requirements.
Charitable remainder trusts may provide benefits for both individuals and charities without violating the partial interest
rule.
A charitable remainder trust (CRT)
is a unique kind of irrevocable trust in which:
The donor, or one or more individuals
designated by the donor, receive(s) income from the trust for life or joint lives, or for a period of up to 20 years, after
which the trust terminates and the trust corpus is distributed to the charitable remainderman.
The income payout period may last
for more than one life, but the present value of the charitable remainder must be 10% or more of the initial value of the
property transferred to the trust. As the income payout period stretches out, (due to young or multiple beneficiaries), the
value of charity’s remainder interest shrinks under time-value-of-money principles, potentially jeopardizing the tax-qualification
of the trust.
Types of CRTs and General
Features
Charitable remainder trusts come
in two main forms:
• charitable remainder annuity trust (CRAT), and
• charitable remainder unitrust (CRUT).
A donor establishes a CRAT by
irrevocably transferring cash or appreciated property to the trustee. The trustee is required by the trust instrument to pay
a specified annual annuity (at least 5% of the initial value of the assets transferred to the trust, but not more than 50%)
to the donor or other designated individual beneficiaries for a certain period of time, often the lives of the beneficiaries,
with the trust property passing to a designated charitable institution at the end of this time period.
The value of the charitable remainder
must be at least 10% of the net fair market value of all property transferred to the trust, as determined at the time of the
transfer. The income beneficiary of a CRAT must receive the required annuity payout each year, even if the trust does not
produce any income. Principal may have to be invaded, if necessary to make the required payout.
A CRUT is an irrevocable trust
that names a charitable institution as remainder beneficiary, and pays one or more income beneficiaries a specified percentage
of the value of the trust assets as revalued each year. If the trust principal rises in value, the income payout also will
increase. The specified percentage must be at least 5%, but not more than 50%. The value of the charitable remainder must
be at least 10% of the net fair market value of all property transferred to the trust, as determined at the time of the transfer.
While the CRAT comes in only one
basic form, the CRUT comes in four sub-varieties:
• the straight or fixed-percentage unitrust;
• the net-income (without make-up) unitrust;
• the net-income with make-up unitrust (NIMCRUT); and
• the so-called "flip unitrust."
Advantages of CRTs for
Donors
Flexible Features
While charitable remainder trusts
must be irrevocable to qualify for tax benefits, they are nevertheless attractive to donors because they offer not only current
income tax benefits but also a number of flexible planning options that can offset some of the potential disadvantages of
irrevocability.
• A charitable remainder trust may be established either
during life (inter vivos) or at death (testamentary).
• The donor can choose a fixed-income payout (charitable
remainder annuity trust) for the individual beneficiary(ies) or a variable-income payout in which the payout amount can grow
(or decline!) with trust principal (charitable remainder unitrust).
• The donor selects the payout rate of the trust, within
certain legal limitations (e.g., 5% minimum, 50% maximum, 10% charitable remainder value, 5% probability test for annuity
trusts). Once the payout rate is selected, it cannot be changed. By careful selection of the trust’s payout percentage,
a donor can elect to optimize the charitable deduction or the payout amount.
• If a CRUT is used, additional contributions can be
made to the trust, if desired, after the initial contribution. Additional contributions cannot be made to a CRAT.
Right to Revoke
The donor selects who will receive
the income from the trust; the income beneficiary(ies) may be the donor and/or others. These income beneficiaries cannot be
changed once they are selected. However, the donor may retain a testamentary right to revoke these income interests by will
to avoid making a completed gift during life for federal gift tax purposes.
Such a retained right to revoke
negates a completed gift from occurring until such time as each income payment is made to an income beneficiary. (The donor
cannot make a gift to himself, of course, if he/she is the income beneficiary). The gift tax annual exclusion may apply to
reduce or eliminate any gift tax for the donor on these annual gifts of trust income to individual beneficiaries if such beneficiaries
are deemed to hold present interests in the trust.
Beneficiaries
The income from a CRT may be paid
to the income beneficiary(ies) for their lifetimes or for a term of years (not to exceed 20), as selected by the donor. Income
may also be paid for the lifetime of beneficiary(ies), to be followed by a term of years.
One charity or several charities
may be named as the remainder beneficiary(ies) of the trust.
Further, the donor may retain
the right to change the charitable remainderman.
The donor names the trustee, which
may be the donor, the charitable remainderman, a third party (e.g., attorney, accountant, relative, etc.), or a financial
institution with trust powers. The donor may retain the right to change the trustee.
Investment Discretion
The trustee of a CRT may exercise
discretion over the investment of the trust assets, so long as the investment is handled in a prudent and reasonable fashion.
The trustee must comply with applicable state laws (e.g., Uniform Prudent Investor Act, Reasonable Man Rule, Reasonable Investor
Rule, Principal and Income Acts, Trust Codes) as well as federal laws (e.g., Internal Revenue Code, Philanthropy Protection
Act).
As a general matter, the trustee
can balance the income needs of the income beneficiaries with the remainder interest (protection of principal) of the charitable
remainderman.